Isocitrate dehydrogenase (IDH)-mutant gliomas are primary malignant brain tumors defined by recurrent mutations in IDH1/2 genes and characterized by distinct molecular subtypes and relatively favorable clinical outcomes. Although these mutations represent early and defining events, recent data suggest that IDH1 mutant glial progenitor cells can reside within the histologically normal-appearing peritumoral cortex, indicating that cells harboring the founding driver mutation can persist beyond the tumor mass while retaining nonmalignant features. These observations challenge a purely gene-centric view of gliomagenesis. In this essay, we review emerging data supporting a multistep and context-dependent model in which the mutant IDH enzyme establishes an epigenetically altered cellular state, with subsequent genetic alterations and lineage-specific constraints that shape malignant progression. We further discuss the conceptual distinction between the "cell-of-mutation" and the "cell-of-origin" and consider how temporal stratification of tumor evolution may inform stage-specific therapeutic strategies along the transition from initiating clones beyond the tumor mass to overt tumors.