Comprehensive comparative evaluation of the eight pediatric estimated glomerular filtration rate equations in a large Korean pediatric patient cohort

Abstract

Introduction: Although estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) are continuously developed for pediatric population, impact of height measurement is often neglected due to variable dynamic growth changes in children. This study aimed to compare differential impacts of eGFR values calculated by six equations that do not use height information.

Materials and methods: 3503 Korean pediatric patients with creatinine/cystatin C assay-based laboratory results from 2008 to 2021 were analyzed for clinical course using a total of 8113 laboratory test results. Baseline eGFR was calculated by eight different equations including two widely used equations incorporating height parameter. Along with the agreement of CKD (chronic kidney disease) stage categorization by different equations, clinical outcome of incident CKD diagnosis in 13 years of study period were compared.

Results: Among a total of 28 pairwise comparisons among eight equations, only 4 combinations of comparisons revealed optimal P15 values (≥80 % concordance), with FAS-age equation being both concordant with two equations using height parameter. Clustering of eight equations by incident CKD diagnosis in subsequent tests also highlighted FAS-age as candidate equation within the same cluster with Schwartz-bedside and FAS-height equations. When the equation values were classified into Kidney Disease Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) CKD stages, the distribution patterns for stage 1 and 5 were significantly different among eGFR equations. FAS-age equation revealed the highest agreement with Schwartz-bedside and FAS-height equations that incorporate the height data.

Conclusions: The eGFR equation type should be considered to establish the eGFR intervals for CKD stage classification, particularly in the pediatric patient population. Cautious interpretation is required for eGFR value along with clinical context.