A Quasi-experimental Study on the Effect of Pre-entry Tuberculosis Screening for Immigrants on Treatment Outcomes in South Korea: A Difference-in-Differences Analysis

Abstract

Objective This study ascertains the effects of the pre-entry tuberculosis (TB) screening policy, which was implemented as

a strategy for managing TB among immigrants, on the treatment outcomes of immigrants in South Korea.

Methods This study linked three different datasets from 2013 to 2018, namely (1) Korean National Tuberculosis Surveillance

System; (2) National Health Information Database for patients diagnosed with TB with ICD code A15-A19, B90, or U84.3;

and (3) Statistics Korea database related to cause of deaths. To identify the effect of the policy, cohorts comprising Korean

and immigrant TB patients notified before (January 1, 2013–December 31, 2015) and after (September 1, 2016–December

31, 2018), the implementations of the policy were established. A difference-in-differences (DID) analysis of the treatment

success and mortality rates was performed.

Results Data from 100,262 TB patients were included in the analysis (before policy implementation: 1240 immigrants and

65,723 Koreans; after policy implementation: 256 immigrants and 33,043 Koreans). The propensity score matching-DID

analysis results showed that the difference in the treatment success rate between immigrants and Koreans decreased significantly,

from 16% before to 6% after the policy implementation. The difference in the mortality rate between the two groups

decreased from − 3% before to − 1% after the policy implementation; however, this difference was insignificant.

Conclusion The treatment outcomes of immigrant TB patients in South Korea improved after the implementation of the preentry

active TB screening policy. Future immigrant TB policies should consider establishing active patient support strategies

and a healthcare collaboration system between countries.