68 91

Cited 13 times in

Interobserver variability in retreatment decisions of recurrent and residual aneurysms

 J.S. McDonald ; R.E. Carter ; D.F. Kallmes ; R.G. Tawk ; S.H. Suh ; A.M. Klunder ; H.J. Cloft ; S.S. Roy ; R.A. Hanel ; J.B. Madigan ; J. Mocco ; K.F. Layton 
 American Journal of Neuroradiology, Vol.34(5) : 1035-1039, 2013 
Journal Title
 American Journal of Neuroradiology 
Issue Date
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The degree of variation in retreatment decisions for residual or recurrent aneurysms among endovascular therapists remains poorly defined. We performed a multireader study to determine what reader and patient variables contribute to this variation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Seven endovascular therapists (4 neuroradiologists, 3 neurosurgeons) independently reviewed 66 cases of patients treated with endovascular coil embolization for ruptured or unruptured aneurysm. Cases were rated on a 5-point scale recommending for whether to retreat and a recommended retreatment type. Reader agreement was assessed by intraclass correlation coefficient and by identifying cases with a “clinically meaningful difference” (a difference in score that would result in a difference in treatment). Variables that affect reader agreement and retreatment decisions were examined by using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test, Pearson 2 test, and linear regression. RESULTS: Overall interobserver variability for decision to retreat was moderate (ICC 0.50; 95% CI, 0.40 – 0.61). Clinically meaningful differences between at least 2 readers were present in 61% of cases and were significantly more common among neuroradiologists than neurosurgeons (P .0007). Neurosurgeons were more likely to recommend “definitely retreat” than neuroradiologists (P .0001). Previously ruptured aneurysms, larger remnant size, and younger patients were associated with more retreat recommendations. Interobserver variability regarding retreatment type was fair overall 0.25 (95% CI, 0.14 – 0.41) but poor for experienced readers 0.14 (95% CI, 0 – 0.34). CONCLUSIONS: There is a large amount of interobserver variability regarding the decision to retreat an aneurysm and the type of retreatment. This variability must be reduced to increase consistency in these subjective outcome measurements.
Appears in Collections:
1. 연구논문 > 1. College of Medicine > Dept. of Radiology
Yonsei Authors
서상현(Suh, Sang Hyun)
사서에게 알리기
Files in This Item:
T201302333.pdf Download
RIS (EndNote)
XLS (Excel)


Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.